|
|
|
|
|
A Nintendo community by the fans!
|
|
|
∧ |
Forum main |
|
|
Top 10 Reasons Negative World Should Start Using Discord For Chat [top ten]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/23/17, 08:30 Edited: 01/23/17, 09:07
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negative World needs a great chat solution |
|
Chat has been a valuable part of the Negative World community for many years now. The most exciting times we use it are during the big events - E3, Nintendo Directs, etc. Just the other day, during the Switch event, there were around 20 people in chat. For me, it was just like old times again and that was a blast.
Some of our best, long-running jokes come from Negative World chat. FloRida singing into a golden taco... you kinda had to be there to understand why that was so funny. But that also kind of proves the point. Chat adds value.
Beyond the big events, there was a time when chat was extremely active nearly every night. I know I participated in those chats and some of my most cherished memories at Negative World are from just shooting the breeze and making jokes with you guys on some random Wednesday when the chat thread got bumped. Zero, Stephen, Stache, Anand, Gui, Ploot, Shadowlink, Jargon... we all used it pretty frequently at one time and got a lot out of it.
So just as a community building feature, I think chat has value here at Negative World.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mibbit was never a great chat solution |
|
Look, Mibbit has one thing going for it - you can sign in with a single click and you're in. That's pretty much the one advantage. But beyond that, it was never very good, even in its heyday. In fact, it's always been inferior to the old IGN chat from the mid-2000s, and that had to be accessed through a long-removed link that got passed around through PMs and had a tendency to go down.
Some problems with Mibbit?
- It's not very stable. People get booted out of it all the time and come back swearing because they've just lost an important part of the conversation.
- It works like absolute stinging hot garbage on a smartphone. There are so many times I wanted to chat with you guys before bed, but I really couldn't because it was so pathetic on my phone. It would crash more frequently than usual. I'd have to tap a hundred times on the little message window to get a field to type in. It was so bad that I just stopped using it there altogether. But the problem never went away. During the Switch event I actually had to get out of bed and go to the computer because I didn't want to miss out on the chat. I shouldn't have to do that in 2017. If I want to lay in bed in my underwear and talk to Mr. Mustache, I should be allowed to do that. This is America, dammit.
- There are no avatars. Instead, we try to figure out who's talking based on a limited number of color choices that get claimed by people as they come in (or if they use chat frequently. Or did use it in 2011. The point is, Purple is still mine and I'll cut you over it.). This has led to actual fights, believe it or not. It's silly.
- No accountability. Anyone can come in with any name. If I want to show up to chat pretending I'm Ploot and tell everyone I'm not really Canadian, I can do that. It's bad. (Well, that example is kinda funny, but it's still really bad.)
- It's never handled pictures very well. You want to drop a photo and actually have people see it? There's a trick to it, but even then it didn't always work for everyone. I lost so many good jokes that way, I'm telling you.
- When a chat is over, it's over. There's no transcript. There's no going back to it. This also means, you know, it's open for backbiting and stuff. Two people want to talk trash about you, there's no way to limit that.
- Who even runs that Mibbit server? Last I asked, Zero basically just knew a guy or something that let us use it. It's not like it was something Negative World built into the site that we have control over. Why have loyalty to that?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The big new feature though? Voice Chat. And it's glorious! |
|
Tonight I was testing out the Discord chat and Fink just said, "Yo Money, let's play some Splatoon." And I thought, why not? It wasn't what I was planning on doing, but what the heck, right?
So what happened? I fired up my Wii U, hopped into Discord voice chat with Fink and Ploot and played about an hour of Splatoon. And it was so much fun. It was the kind of experience everyone at Negative World could and should be having with each other. We were laughing, cutting up, talking about the game, talking about the Switch. Stephen and Pokefreak joined us, too. We got a preview of some of Pokefreak's thoughts on the latest Pokemon game. Heard Trish in the background talking to Finn, even. It was really just a delight. There's no downside, here.
Personally, I can be really self conscious about things like Voice Chat. I think of myself as a writer and I think, "What if I'm not as funny on voice chat as I am when I write? Or what if I say something stupid?" I also hate the sound of my own voice - I sound like a dude with a permanent cold. So I can be very neurotic about talking to people on the phone.
But I'm telling you, even with those thoughts in my head, I think Voice Chat is the kind of thing you think you don't need until you actually participate in it. Then you wonder why you bothered going without it. If you don't think you want Voice Chat, I say try it first.
Currently, it's the missing component in our Nintendo game sessions. It's true that Nintendo is about to roll out a Switch app, so there may be opportunities in the future to put something like this together using that app, but for now this is way too easy and way to fun to miss out on.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negative World really could use a new community building tool |
|
Let's face it, Negative World has been pretty dead over the last few months. I'd even say we've been in a funk. Not right now! I'm being serious! Geez!We don't have to be ashamed to admit it. It's not like the community had a big falling out or anything like that. Yeah, maybe we shouldn't have talked so much about politics, but I don't think that's really our problem. I think it's just that there hasn't been much Nintendo news to fire the engines of conversation. So we've filled it up with other things - chatting about politics, music, movies... whatever we could talk about. And that's ok, but those topics are not as comfortable for this community. It's not why any of us came to Negative World in the first place. We came here because we love playing Nintendo games. Frankly, I think we made some mistakes. We should have been playing video games with each other that whole time. I really do believe that Discord is ironically named, because I can imagine it bringing some harmony back to Negative World. Like, my game with Fink and Ploot just now - it was a great opportunity to catch up with some friends, share our love for Nintendo, and play a great game together. And it all grew out of just one stray comment by Fink on Discord. Imagine that happening every night. I'm super excited by the idea! Yeah, sure, the counter argument is that someone could already bump a Splatoon thread if they wanted to play, but we all know that's a different thing altogether. Threads feel so permanent and we're not in the habit of bumping them or checking them for something so casual as that. Plus, if I see a Splatoon thread and, if I'm not already thinking about Splatoon, I'm probably not going to open it. I'd never have known Fink wanted to play. Whereas tonight we were just chatting about any old thing and the decision to play Splatoon just grew organically out of that conversation. This sort of thing is good for the community and I think it's something we've been sorely missing.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Don't worry about having to download the app or signing up to an account. It's super basic and easy. |
|
I heard in the other thread some disapproval about having to make an account or run an app to use chat. Those worries are for nothing. It's simpler than just about any online account I've ever set up. Yes, you do have to set up an account - but you set up that account in like two minutes. Maybe less. I bet you could time yourself and set it up in 30 seconds. You don't even have to verify your email right away, so you could use some throwaway email if you're worried about that. And that two minutes prevents spoofing, so that alone is the least you can do for such a good trade-off. Ok, so I guess you're just the mascot of this article now. Fine. Why are you dressed like Randy 'Macho Man' Savage with a Tool Belt, though?As for whether or not it'll run on everyone's devices, I admit that's something that remains to be seen. But you can make that argument until everyone's using apps that are compatible with Windows 95. At a certain point we have to move on and hope as many people as possible can come along for the ride. Anyway, tonight, Fink was running voice chat directly from a Safari browser in an operating system that's 5 versions old. And it worked just fine. Sure, there may be a few people who'll have some challenges getting Discord to work, but I don't think that's worth holding the whole community back, particularly when you consider the people who can't use Discord probably aren't using Mibbit regularly anyway.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
One of the things I wish I had addressed now is that Discord shouldn't replace any of the key features of Negative World. I'm against setting up too many standing chat rooms on Discord, as that begins to look like an alternative Negative World forum rather than an alternative chat room from Mibbit. So I don't think it'll have a bad effect on forum traffic, except maybe in a few of the more social oriented ones (the Online Now one and, more sadly, possibly the Community Thread). I think the trade off could be worth it, though, as it'll be easier to game together. @Mop it upI wasn't aware until this moment that we had any members of the forum who were hearing impaired. I think we can still be respectful and inclusive in Discord as with any other chat. It is true that voice chat becomes a problem, but I don't know a technical way around that, except to just be considerate and include written comments along with some of our voice chatting. I'm sure we can work that out through experimentation, though. The idea is to bring us together, so I hope that's the spirit we can approach the technology with. BTW, we were talking just last night about wanting to play some MARIO Kart with you, so I definitely think we're all up for some spontaneous gaming, soon. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
@J.K. RikiWell, let's start here - this conversation is about adopting a new chat service at Negative World. No one is asking anyone to accept Discord as their personal Lord and Savior. So let's keep this in perspective. This isn't something we have to take some big philosophical stand on. It's just a question of which chat service gives us more bang for our buck. (Buck, in this case, being metaphorical as both services are absolutely free.) But I have to admit, I personally don't understand your point-of-view against creating a Discord account. To get the obvious out of the way: That line of thinking would keep you from posting on Negative World at all, since you have to have an account to post here. Beyond that, I address the concern in my Top Ten by pointing out how easy it is to set up an account. This is a needless barrier (heck, Mustache is already posting in Discord with his account, and he's usually the holdout on things like this. If he can do it, you can do it). If that's still a dealbreaker, then that's up to you. But to turn around and ask the forum to not update the chat service to something clearly better just because you simply don't want to take the two minutes to create an account is not really fair, either. You mention feeling burned out on social media - which is something I generally relate to. I'm about an inch from dumping my Facebook and scaling back my social media presence, too. So you're not alone, there. But Discord is just an extension of what you already do at Negative World. It's not like we're asking you to participate in some broader Discord social media environment, like Facebook. Once you sign in, you could use it practically like you use Mibbit, just without the crashes if you wanted. And I'd personally bet money that you'll like it enough to at least play some Mario Kart with us or something. I'd also just say, personally, that I'd like to see you on Discord with us. I wouldn't write like 7 paragraphs here if I didn't want you there. I know sometimes this place can be combative or people can jock each other a little bit, but it's my sincere hope that Discord could be a way for the community to just play more Nintendo games together. And that's kind of the whole point. While Ploot maybe could have worded it a little more generously, I think he is right about one thing, though: You're taking a hardline stance on an innocuous product you haven't even used, yet. And that's a total Green Eggs and Ham thing. You haven't tried but you're convinced you won't like it. I understand it's not about the product, per se, but the need for an account. But from the perspective of someone who used Mibbit extensively for years (not just at E3 or during Directs) and who had no particular interest in Discord until two days ago, your position just makes little sense. This is just simply a better service and the barrier to entry is so minute that it seems pointless to fight it. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
∧ |
Forum main |
|
|