Got it in from the library, but traveling to visit family so will have to wait until our return.

Eventually, though!

Despite my thinking that I wouldn't feel like going back to the game, I had an urge to start playing again. And it's still fantastic. But now I just feel like I want more levels again.

I know this is an unreasonable ask, but I kind of feel like I would have wanted 200-ish levels instead of 100-ish, just so that they could have explored every single idea at least twice. Like, go nuts with a creative idea, and then go even nuts-er in an almost irresponsible way. Combine shit in inadviceable ways.

Put me inside a friggin' pinball machine populated by hoppos, bloomps and robbirds, have me escape from rising lava using hoppycats to push up platforms while avoiding some kind of lava smackerel cruising the bottom of the screen like the fish from Balloon Fight, or just give me more flippin' ghost houses! More! I want more!

I gotta say it’s crazy to me that Mario and crew just feel so much better to control than in the NSMB games. I don’t know if I’d say it’s Super Mario World level, but everything feels more responsive. And it’s great to be able to flick loops shells upwards again. NSMB just never felt like a proper evolution of Mario World and this feels much more in line with that.

Alright, finally finished all of the stages. Awesome game. Best 2D Mario in a long, long time.

BUT. Whoever decided that you should end the game with a complicated section WHERE YOU CAN'T SEE WHAT YOU'RE DOING should just... give up on game design. Get out. Go sell cars or something. It felt like sheer luck that I got past that. And of course I kind of forgot about the purple coins until I got past the section with the first one, so if I want to be a completionist I need to go get that purple coin and then beat the level again. Oof.

That aside, spectacular game.

@Zero

Final Mario levels for the last decade or so have felt really incongruent with the rest of their respective games, focusing their level design less on creative combinations of elements and more on reflex test gauntlets. I 100%ed Wonder, except for that last level, which I won't be touching. I get the motivation, giving the player one last thing to chew on for a long time, but I think I'd prefer a more definitive ending than that.

Having thought of this game as being a bit forgettable, I revisited it a bit yesterday and today, and it's really great. "It's the best 2D Mario game since Super Mario World" is a hyperbolic way of phrasing it, but put differently: it's the pinnacle of the NSMB body of work.

And then, to test that feeling, I played some Mario Maker 2, and had the same experience I usually get from that game: unease. People get wildly creative with it, and as a sandbox playground it's hilarious, but something about even the supposed traditional levels feel very off to me; they're missing that subconscious flow you can only get by throwing millions of dollars at a team of the best level designers in the world for half a decade. It's really not a fair comparison at all, but that's just it, it's not a comparison. As a Mario game, Wonder is way better, straight-up!

It's going in the rotation.

I guess I haven't posted my thoughts here yet! I played through Wonder near launch. Just far enough to roll credits and leave myself with some fun stuff for a replay. It was fun, but I was actually really happy with the momentum-heavy core mechanics of NSMB, unlike (apparently) everyone else in the world. I'm not sure that Wonder was such an improvement in that aspect. Although the graphical style of NSMB was clean and readable, Wonder's IS a step up. Not sure that I'd say that about the music. I was pretty fond of the NSMB themes, BAHs and all!

BAH! BAH!

But, yeah, it didn't feel like a radical break from NSMB to me. More of an evolution on the same base 2.5D chassis. The gimmick-based levels were an interesting change. Some of them were definitely fun and inventive. But I feel like that emphasis on novelty and surprise could hurt the replay value of the game in the long run. Like rewatching a Shyamalan movie! On the other hand, the badges are a cool idea that should enhance replay value and player expression. We'll see, I guess. Some of the multiplayer stuff was interesting, too. I wish that they focused a bit more on racing-type mechanics, though. Racing through levels in Super Mario Maker 2 was kind of amazing. (When it worked.)

I definitely enjoyed it, but I'm not sure if it bowled me over.