A Nintendo community
by the fans!
∧  Forum main
 + 
Order of the Sinking Star Discussion (Nintendo Switch 2) [game]
 
Order of the Sinking Star on the Switch 2
9/10 from one rating

Welcome to the official discussion thread for Order of the Sinking Star on the Switch 2!

To start, please add this game to your log, add it to your collection (if applicable), and (when you are ready) rate it using the link above!

URL to share (right click and copy)
05/14/26, 20:24  
 
Why not sign up for a (free) account?
   
 


😍
05/14/26, 20:25   
@Secret_Tunnel
Never heard of this but that's a nice trailer. The Mole Mania superfan in me is very much intrigued.
05/14/26, 22:42   
I got to the Witness far too late so I’ll have to get this one on the sooner side.
05/14/26, 23:15   
Edited: 05/14/26, 23:15
This does look like Mole Mania doesn’t it?
05/15/26, 15:09   
@GameDadGrant
Single-screen (action) puzzlers were a pretty vital genre throughout the 80s and 90s. Adventures of Lolo trilogy, Fire 'n Ice, Mole Mania, Catrap, even Donkey Kong '94 and Wrecking Crew apply to a certain extent. You hardly see them anymore so a modern version of one could be pretty awesome. I think Baba Is You is probably the most well-known recent example.
05/15/26, 17:51   
@GameDadGrant
@TriforceBun

They call these sorts of tile-based block-pushing games Sokoban-style puzzle games these days. Baba Is You is indeed easily my favorite of the genre, with Stephen's Sausage Roll as a solid second. People also love A Monster's Expedition and a few others, but they've always felt a bit basic to me, like they're exploring way too many little permutations on every little interaction. Order of the Sinking Star looks like it's going Baba Is You style: there are so many moving parts that every level feels totally unique.

Jonathan Blow's previous game The Witness is probably in my Top 5 favorite games of all time. This one apparently has 500 hours worth of puzzles! Easily my most anticipated game right now.
05/15/26, 18:38   
Cannot wait! The Witness is easily one of my favorite games of all time and I have no doubt that this game will be similarly brilliant.
05/21/26, 17:33   
@TheBigG753

No big straight lines to save you this time.
05/25/26, 07:56   
@Shadowlink

We'll see about that!
05/26/26, 17:09   
For anyone interested, there is a demo on Steam available for the next week. Apparently you are able to play a rather large portion of the game.
06/15/26, 21:42   
@TheBigG753

I was going back and forth on whether I want to play this or not. I'll be playing the full game on Switch 2 so my progress from this demo wouldn't carry over, and do I really want to disjoint my experience by playing an unfinished demo a few months prior to launch in the first place?

I decided to try the demo out for an hour or so just to get a taste.

...and it wouldn't run on either computer I tried it on! So there's that decision made for me.
06/16/26, 02:28   
Hey, this thread has 13,000 views! Is this one of the top Google results for Order of the Sinking star? Look alive, folks.

(I unironically love that the first responses in this thread are our resident Gen Xers comparing it to MOLE MANIA.)

As someone who loves diving into obscure message boards to see what people are saying about games I love, I'll take this opportunity to pontificate about why I'm particularly looking forward to this game.

I'm coming to believe that outside of happiness, love, the works—the type of stuff you could achieve through drugs or wireheading—the point of the universe is understanding. Contemplation, as Aristotle would put it. But I'm also not quite high IQ enough to be a mathematician who can do multidimensional symbolic manipulation in his head, so I need geometric representations of this stuff. Better yet, toys that I can poke and prod. Better yet: games that are designed to show me all the cool stuff on a silver platter.

I think Jonathan Blow and Nintendo are kindred spirits in this pursuit. He's a bit more principled and higher-brow, but I don't think it's fair to say that Nintendo is just really good at providing cheap entertainment either. They're clearly tastemakers, and MKW and Bananza prove they haven't lost that goal. Capcom and Sega can still make great arcade games that challenge you to master some domain by solving it faster and faster, but the Nintendo style of design where they're specifically trying to illustrate as wide of a variety of creative implications of their mechanics is essentially dead in the AAA space, and it's rare amongst indies too. Blow gets it, and he articulates it better than anyone.

So the whole pitch for this game being "1400 surprises" is tantalizing. You might say it has potential to be the best game ever. Why I expect it to be merely a stepping stone to that pinnacle is that, as a turn-based puzzle game, it's not quite tapping into the player's muscle memory. There's a whole computational subsystem baked into our bodies that Mario takes advantage of. That's how you really communicate these ideas in a humane way. I mean, who am I to criticize an upcoming masterpiece for not being even more of a masterpiece, but if there is a higher mountain, I suspect that that's where it'd be. I'll never reach it.

Anyway. I'm hyped, and it'll be hilarious if this is a better Zelda game than the OOT remake.
06/16/26, 06:29   
Edited: 06/16/26, 06:35


Coming October 8!

I've completely cleared the slate for this. Played, replayed, and often replayed again every other game in existence that I know of which appeals to me. My affairs are in order.

...and hey, the last one was Mole Mania! It is a fair comparison to Order of the Sinking Star, I shouldn't have made fun of Triforcebun and Grant. I didn't realize how tile-based and puzzley Mole Mania is. I only played the first couple worlds and then had my fill—it seems like you spend a lot of time "Sokobaning," just sort of shuffling objects around to squeeze into the right place, something Blow has said they're avoiding with OotSS—but it's a great enough concept that they should totally have made a sequel.
08/18/26, 17:39   
@Secret_Tunnel
Let's go! Did you play the Steam Demo? Can we get a Switch Demo? Ask the guy for one plz

And yeah, love me some Mole Mania. I too have a limited stomach for block-pushing but for whatever reason that game just keeps my attention throughout.
08/18/26, 18:06   
@TriforceBun

I never did try the demo! It didn't work on my laptop when I first tried it, progress doesn't carry over cross-platform, and it sounded like the game was still a work-in-progress. Figured it wasn't meant to be and I'd wait for the full Switch 2 version.
08/19/26, 01:34   
Reviews are up and looking good.

I've been playing quite a bit of this myself, actually! It's largely pretty brilliant at points, although I have to be in the right mood for it if that makes sense. Gotta be ready to fire on all cylinders.

One thing I'm a little mixed on is that apparently the first few hours are all pretty much remakes of 4 other indie games, which gives me sort of a funny feeling. I even verified this myself by looking up the puzzles from those games and they're just about identical as far as I can tell. I wouldn't use a word as strong as "plagiarism" since it was done with the blessing of other creators, but it is a little odd that the game doesn't make this explicit from the get-go (like other remakes do).
10/07/26, 19:05   
Edited: 10/07/26, 19:06
@TriforceBun

You got a code? Lucky! Are you reviewing it? How's the performance on Switch 2?

It's worth noting that Blow paid the original creators for their games too. There's been a little bit of drama over when and how they exactly get credited in the game. The Witness had a very elaborate, meta credits sequence, and it sounds like Order of the Sinking Star wants to indulge in that bit of fun too, with the trade-off that there's no up-front credit. That said, the original creators' names are splashed all over the game's marketing, Steam page, and so on. I would rest easy knowing that the majority of players will have that context going in. (On the other hand, how cool would it be to start playing this game not knowing what you're in for...?)

All the reviews, regardless of what score they gave the game, seem to agree on three points:

1. Wow, this really is a collection of 1000+ masterfully crafted puzzles.
2. Oh crap, I don't know if I have what it takes to complete 1000+ masterfully crafted puzzles.
3. The story itself is a puzzle, so A. 10% of the way in I have no idea if it'll pay off or not, and B. if you were expecting a break from puzzles, joke's on you!

Polygon's review is surprisingly classy in that it admits that it's not fair to review a 500-hour long game in one month and omits a score. It's also refreshing to see a reviewer point out the game's autofictional (is that the right word?) elements and try and grapple with what Thekla is trying to do. Most of the reviews I read were still in "a good puzzle game should make you feel smart" levels of insight, but Polygon's reviewer—despite not being personally aligned with Blow's worldview—acknowledges that the designers here are attempting something that's deeply important to them.

After a decade of playing BOTW, I'm still uncovering new feelings about it. I can only imagine how our perceptions of Order of the Sinking Star will change in the years it'll take to complete it.

It's also cosmically hilarious that this game took ten years to make and is coming out the week that people start using AI to decompile and mash up pre-existing games. It's all unfun slop so far, but Blow's "game design supercollider" concept could very well be what the future of video games looks like: a marketplace of mechanics and ideas being constantly remixed and recombined. In that sense, Sinking Star couldn't be more timely. (In other news, OpenAI's math results from last night are proving just how infinitely complex and fun our universe really is, and how going forward what will be most important for us humans on an intellectual level is having interfaces through which we can understand all these deep mathematical truths that the machines will be plumbing. That's puzzle games!)

Secret_Tunnel said:
You might say it has potential to be the best game ever. Why I expect it to be merely a stepping stone to that pinnacle is that, as a turn-based puzzle game, it's not quite tapping into the player's muscle memory. There's a whole computational subsystem baked into our bodies that Mario takes advantage of. That's how you really communicate these ideas in a humane way.

I also want to say that I've come to disagree with this caveat. The only games (or at least, game templates) that really use timing and muscle memory for communicating ideas in a Blow-ian fashion are Mario (a game about momentum and trajectories) and Rhythm Heaven (a game about rhythm!). There are plenty of other endlessly fascinating games that don't do this and they aren't any worse for it.
10/07/26, 20:02   
Edited: 10/07/26, 20:19
@Secret_Tunnel
Interesting thoughts! The scope of this game does make me wonder at what point you need to be at a game to have an accurate review. It only makes sense to finish story-driven games (even long ones like Dragon Quest) to get the full picture. But a puzzler boasting 1000+ mind-benders and 500+ hours to get through? A little tricky, especially when Order of the Sinking Star hints that the gameplay will grow in complexity and intrigue as one gets further. I don't think it's reasonable to expect a reviewer to spend that amount of time on a single game prior to the review; sometimes you just have to draw the line at the point where you think you've gotten a strong representation of the game's content.

As for the game itself, I'm having a good time! The puzzle designs are tight and clever, with most of them having some sort of teachable moment or "twist." Very rarely do I just stumble upon a solution with no additional realization to accompany it. I think they made a concentrated effort to focus on logical approaches and not get too bogged down in very exact, 100-step solutions in these. So it's not just a bunch of Lufia 2's World's Most Difficult Trick!

That said, of the four gameplay types I definitely have a preference. Hearty Heroes of Hauling is probably my favorite since it's fairly straightforward but regularly introduces interesting new wrinkles. Mirror Isles is neat but I'm currently stuck on that overworld and can't seem to access any past the first few. Skipping Stones is one I'm really having trouble wrapping my head around and was the first one where I had to look up a solution. Promise is kind of a breath of fresh air; it feels overwhelming at first but so far the actual puzzle parts have been more bite-sized than they seem.
10/08/26, 15:59   
I've only played a couple hours of this so far!

The first thing that sticks out to me is how different the two worlds are that I've tried so far. Heroes of Hauling is a series of one-off levels that I've been breezing through easily... up until I reached this one involving three goblins that I've been absolutely stumped on.

So I tried out some Skipping Stones, and I was surprised to find that it has a totally different structure! It reminds me a ton of Alan Hazelden's other game, A Monster's Expedition. Similar to that game, I've found Skipping Stones to be pretty difficult (way harder than Heroes), and the moment-to-moment puzzles haven't grabbed me so far, despite the tantalizing interlocking open-world strucure. I'm curious how similar Mirror Isles will be.

I'm waiting for a long chunk of contiguous free time to dig into The Promise, which sounds delicious. Some history here: this one's based on PROMESST by Sean Barrett, which is itself an homage to CORRYPT by Michael Brough, aka "smestorp," which "PROMESST" is an anagram of. Brough is another genius game designer; his games CORRYPT, 868-HACK, and Cinco Paus are all brilliant, so if The Promise captures any of that spirit at all, it'll be the high point of the game for me.

I loved Order of the Sinking Star's intro sequence. It has some clear thematic (if not direct) ties to The Witness. More context: the title of the game is a reference to the poem "Ulysses" (not to be confused with the novel):

"How dull it is to pause, to make an end,
To rust unburnish'd, not to shine in use!
As tho' to breathe were life! Life piled on life
Were all too little, and of one to me
Little remains: but every hour is saved
From that eternal silence, something more,
A bringer of new things; and vile it were
For some three suns to store and hoard myself,
And this gray spirit yearning in desire
To follow knowledge like a sinking star,
Beyond the utmost bound of human thought."


The puzzles so far in this very early game are neat enough, but it's all the crazy stuff it's doing with structure and theme that's got me excited to play more.
10/11/26, 00:32   
Looks like they renamed The Promise to Vault of the Laser-something-or-other. Must've been a last-minute change during the narrative pass.

No surprise, it's my favorite section so far. Very trippy, and it has a unique puzzle-feel. So far it's less about knowing what your end goal is and navigating a huge state space to find the path there and more about just sort of following your immediate possible actions where they lead you. Like untangling a knot, almost. Reminds me of a Zelda dungeon with lots of keys.

It's funny that my Mystery Dungeon muscle memory is conflicting with this game's controls a little. I'll get used to it.
10/12/26, 00:24   
Edited: 10/12/26, 00:53
∧  Forum main
 +