A Nintendo community
for the fans, by the fans!
Browse    1  2  3  
Mario vs Donkey Kong: Tipping Stars Discussion (Nintendo 3DS) [game]
 
Paul K
8.25/10 from 2 user ratings

Welcome to the official discussion thread for Mario vs Donkey Kong: Tipping Stars on the 3DS! To start, please add this game to your log, add it to your collection (if applicable), and (when you are ready) rate it using the link above!

This will be the official thread for general discussion on this game, but there may be other threads with more specific discussions. If there are any details about this game that you believe should be in this post, please contact a moderator and ask if they can add them.

END AUTOMATED TEXT. THREAD CREATOR INFORMATION BELOW.

Did anybody receive the advertisement for this game on their Wii U systems? I certainly did, and I decided to take the plunge.
I haven't played a Mario vs. DK "Minis" game since the very first (not counting the original Mario vs. DK) since the theme never really appealed to me. For whatever reason though, I grabbed this and it happens to be one fun piece of entertainment!

I tried the Wii U version first, then tried out the 3DS version. Aside from one of the levels in the first world starting slightly differently, the games are identical (minus the resolution of course). The 3DS game doesn't have any 3D either, unless you count the splash screen before you boot up the game.

A little quibble though: The games don't share saves, so owning both versions, while nice, is sort of pointless. The main levels are nifty, but once you've bested them there is no fun in doing them all over again. Granted, you can always download community levels on either version, so I guess it doesn't hurt to have both.
That said, being Nintendo, I didn't expect them to share saves, but I was hoping to be surprised.

Anyway, check it out! It's a neat little game.

URL to share this content (right click and copy link)
Posted: 03/06/15, 04:48:47  - Edited by 
ploot
  on: 03/06/15, 05:21:27
[ Share ]
 
Why not sign up for a (free) account and create your own content?
 
ploot
Nobody? Seriously? Aww, I wanted to try some NW peeps' levels out.
Posted: 03/08/15, 02:23:42
DrFinkelstein
@ploot

I'll jump in on this, just not yet. I'm still finishing off Pokemon Shuffle and other games.
Posted: 03/08/15, 02:33:47
carlosrox
I'm looking to get the Wii U version soon.

They're basically one and the same, no?
Posted: 03/08/15, 08:20:49
DrFinkelstein
@carlosrox

Almost exactly. Levels themselves should be totally the same. You get a download code for the other one when you buy a copy anyway. Thinking of sharing that code or using both?
Posted: 03/08/15, 16:19:11
deathly_hallows
@DrFinkelstein
Oh wow it's a code, meaning you could split the cost? That seems crazy, I would assume they'd just unlock it on your eShop account so it's linked to your Nintendo ID to prevent you from passing it off to someone else. This seems like exactly the kind of thing Nintendo tries to avoid.
Posted: 03/08/15, 22:54:55
DrFinkelstein
@deathly_hallows

I haven't tried it myself but I have heard nothing refuting this. I'm pretty sure you get a code on your game to use but I don't know if it has any understanding of what account it's on.
Posted: 03/09/15, 01:33:20
ploot
Yep, you can share the code.

On a side note: Some of the stages are actually slightly different between the versions.
I'm not really sure why, but it's true! One example is stage 1-3. Both are just slightly different.

Also, I spent a few hours constructing a stage last night and shared it... Nobody's played it yet. Boooooo.
Posted: 03/09/15, 01:48:34
DrFinkelstein
@ploot

Maybe I'll nab this tomorrow since I just finished Captain Toad. Plus I don't want to leave you hanging! I'm just not sure if I wanna be nice and share my second code with my girlfriend or nephew, or if I'll want this on both systems. They don't sync up at all do they if you have both?
Posted: 03/09/15, 03:01:31
ploot
@DrFinkelstein
No, the saves don't sync, unfortunately.
Posted: 03/09/15, 04:27:53
Guillaume
Actually a RFN listener sent us the Wii U code after buying the 3DS version for himself, so you can definitely share it: I got my copy for free.

The game is very much standard M&DK fare for now. I loved Minis on the Move for being different, and now this return to form is underwhelming. But I haven't played any user-made stages yet, and that's basically the one unique feature the game has (if you forget the fact that March of the Minis had it).
Posted: 03/09/15, 16:23:34
GameDadGrant
@Guillaume

Not to mention Minis March Again! and Mini-Land Mayhem! had that level-sharing feature as well.
Posted: 03/09/15, 18:05:48
ludist210
I'd like to get the Wii U version at some point, but I've got a lot on my plate right now (gaming-wise and otherwise) plus our cash flow isn't exactly great at the moment...so I'll wait. It looks good though.
Posted: 03/09/15, 18:16:42
deathly_hallows
So this really isn't like cross-buy (in the familiar PSN way) at all. I don't really see the point of Nintendo doing this, there is no way this will become a viable model for the future because Nintendo isn't going to get in the habit of giving away codes to free games, and if it doesn't share a save it kind of defeats the whole point anyway. *shrugs*
Posted: 03/09/15, 19:44:08  - Edited by 
deathly_hallows
  on: 03/09/15, 19:44:51
anon_mastermind
I am shocked that there isn't anything unique about this game besides the tipping stars. I almost feel like they should have held this back and added something more substantial or offered it at a much reduced price. I feel like they jacked it up to $20 just because it's cross-buy.
Posted: 03/09/15, 19:50:22
deathly_hallows
@anon_mastermind
Instead of $10 for each version charge $20 and get both, seems logical in a very illogical sort of way. When they announced this cross-buy thing I was hoping they were testing the waters for making more games compatible across both systems, imagine a Fire Emblem game that you can play on either console or handheld and your save always goes with you, that would be so freaking cool and I hope that's what the future has in store.
Posted: 03/09/15, 20:46:50
ploot
I suppose I'm not underwhelmed because I skipped most of these games until now.
I'm having lots of fun designing levels.

As for the "cross-buy" yeah, it makes little sense.
Posted: 03/09/15, 21:53:45
carlosrox
I can share my code when I get the game, I have no need for 3DS version.

I haven't played one of these games before so it'll be new and fresh to me.
Posted: 03/09/15, 22:06:27  - Edited by 
carlosrox
  on: 03/09/15, 22:07:30
Anand
Pretty pricey, considering the previous entry! I agree that the cross-buy+double-the-price is a weird combo. But I'll pick it up eventually. Eventually, eventually. It's a quality series, if you ignore the crappy first entry. So there are no new gameplay twists in this entry?

@GameDadGrant
Yeah, but all of the levels were auto-playing Rube Goldberg machines...
Posted: 03/10/15, 21:05:58  - Edited by 
Anand
  on: 03/10/15, 21:06:41
Guillaume
Nice stage, ploot! For some reason, it didn't show up the first time I searched for Friend-made stages, though, even though I had already seen the Miiverse post for it. Have you published more stages?
Posted: 03/11/15, 17:01:21
ploot
@Guillaume
Thanks! I feel it might've done a little better if I took a better thumbnail snapshot. Although it is a little sloppy overall.

As for more stages, I crafted a couple but haven't published yet. Are you making stages?
Posted: 03/12/15, 00:16:16
Browse    1  2  3