@warerare The thing is, I kind of get his point and to a certain degree you are comparing apples and oranges. It'd be like saying album of the year and choosing a 3 song EP over all of the full lengths.
...but on the other hand, if you asked me what the best album of the year was and there was an awesome 3 song EP that was better than the full-lengths, I'd pick it. I'd also pick a digital download for GOTY if I felt like one was the best game of the year. I'm not sure that I have ever felt that way though, despite loving a lot of digital downloads.
Still, this is, in part, why I decided to not have an "overall" Negative World GOTY and just stick to platforms and such.
A lot of these digital versus retail lines are just going to get more and more blurred moving forward anyway.