A Nintendo community
by the fans!
  Forum main
 + 
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Nintendo Wii) discussion [game]
 
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword on the Wii
9.03/10 from 69 user ratings

Welcome to the official discussion thread for The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword on the Wii!

To start, please add this game to your log, add it to your collection (if applicable), and (when you are ready) rate it using the link above!

Reviews:
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Review (Nintendo Wii) (4.2)  by  

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Nintendo Wii) Review (8.9)  by  

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Nintendo Wii) Review (9.2)  by  

Visit The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword in our game database (add it to your collection/log and rate it!)


Alrighty everyone, the game is finally out in all primary regions.... IDreamofHime was the first to receive their copy here on the boards. This is the place to discuss it!!!

Welcome to the thread on Negative World where all wondrous Zelda talk can occur. I would recommend that if you wanna talk about deeper-game stuff as we get going, perhaps spoiler-tag it and then describe outside of spoilers where in the game it is. The recent Super Mario 3D Land Discussion Thread is a good example. That'll allow people who aren't too far to read the thread without actually spoiling stuff for them. Just try to be courteous but definitely have fun with the game and discussions!!


Have ye what it takes?

Be sure to hit up the Skyward Sword Game Page and add the game to your collection once you've received yours. Be sure to mark it as "Playing" while you work on it and after you're played it sufficiently, give it a score you deem fitting!

If you've beaten the game, click on over to roykoopa64's Skyward Sword story/ ending discussion (SPOILERS), and general thoughts thread! It's like this thread part deux!!

URL to share (right click and copy)
11/17/11, 19:54    Edited: 09/20/12, 03:19
 
Why not sign up for a (free) account?
   
 
Whoever gave this game a 10/10 and said it was perfect/the best Zelda has been smoking CRACK.

But anyone who says this game is awful is smoking just as much crack.

TP is still better so far, and from what I've noticed and other people bitching about collectathons, I think it'll stay that way. But it shits on MM and WW so anyone complaining about SS yet praises those two are also smoking crack.
12/05/11, 23:23   
@carlosrox

I'm convinced it is you that is smoking crack. I don't know where SS will fall exactly but it will definitely be below MM and WW.
12/05/11, 23:31   
@stephen08

That's not a bad point. I don't know exactly what throws my "tedium toggle" other than to say that the switch definitely requires different amounts of pressure in different genres/series/games.
12/05/11, 23:47   
No, you are both filthy smokers. TP had pacing issues in the wrong half of the game (first half), and SS's fast Link shows how bad the wolf really is. SS is the best.
12/05/11, 23:53   
I can't tell you where SS falls overall, but I can tell you this. It STOMPS on Wind Waker.

Wind Waker is the worst 3D Zelda, full stop. This is a basic law of the universe.
12/06/11, 00:00   
@Shadowlink

Nah, worst 3D one is probably Twilight.
12/06/11, 00:18   
12/06/11, 00:21   
Ocarina of Time > Majora's Mask > Wind Waker > Skyward Sword > Twilight Princess

I think Skyward Sword might be better than Wind Waker, but it feels too samey for it to rank it any higher.
12/06/11, 00:34   
@carlosrox

What if I love all of those games? Perhaps I'm smoking some good crack.

@Secret_Tunnel

Add a "> everything" to the end and swap MM/TWW and you have something pretty close to my list. Then again, I haven't done this fetch stuff yet...
12/06/11, 00:48   
@Secret_Tunnel

Slide Ocarina in after Wind Waker and I think that will be my order when all is said and done.
12/06/11, 00:49   
@Secret_Tunnel

Move Wind Waker to the bottom where it belongs.

At the moment I have OoT>MM>TP>WW. SS will go in the middle somewhere, but I'm not quite sure where yet.
12/06/11, 00:50   
All the 3D Zeldas are amazing. 5/5, A++, 10/10, whatever. So the order is not that important IMO
12/06/11, 00:52   
@GelatinousEncore

The 2D titles are way better. That is fact. No arguing!
12/06/11, 01:35   
@TriforceBun

The "> everything" was implied.
12/06/11, 01:38   
@VofEscaflowne Totally disagree, except for A Link to the Past, and maybe Awakening.

By the way, would it be awesome if the game looked like this the entire time?



I can't decide. I wish they would've really gone to town with the brush strokes, but at the same time I'm not sure if it would work.
12/06/11, 01:39   
Edited: 12/06/11, 01:59
Eh, I'd still say Skyward Sword is overall a better game than Twilight Princess and Wind Waker. I mean, I can rage about just as many things in those games.

The series, overall, hasn't been what it used to since it was put in the hands of Aonuma... I still don't understand what this guy did to inherit one of the most important franchises in gaming, but I think it's a mistake.

That statement about Miyamoto "personally handling" Zelda on Wii U has given me some hope, but not much. He has said similar things in the past. He really should, though. The Mario team knows exactly what they are doing, but the Zelda team needs some love and attention.
12/06/11, 02:42   
@GelatinousEncore

I was sort of making a joke Although I suppose it wasn't very funny
12/06/11, 03:04   
@VofEscaflowne I didn't notice, lol.

@Hinph I agree with your comment about Aonuma. When one analyzes the Zelda franchise and compares it to other Nintendo franchises it becomes clear. The series started to degrade, taking steps both forward and backward since the guy was put in charge. I think he was first hired to design the dungeons in OoT and because of that the interns fell in love with him or something.
12/06/11, 03:06   
Edited: 12/06/11, 03:08
Ocarina > MM > TP > SS >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> TWW

Fact.

Should be interesting to see if these fetch-quest segments are just as brutal on my second playthrough. I'm getting close to the "Between 3rd and 4th Dungeon Bore-a-Thon" again...
12/06/11, 03:22   
@TheBigG753 That's not that bad, I think there are much more annoying things to do later in the game.
12/06/11, 03:23   
  Forum main
 +