A Nintendo community
for the fans, by the fans!
Browse    1  2  
Do you actually feel comfortable platforming in a 3D space? [roundtable]
 
I know, I know, you can do it. So can I. But it's more of a subconscious mental exercise. A shadow game, helped by years of experience. Do you guys really feel comfortable judging distance, and such, in a 3D platformer? Assuming no camera issues, do you think it could ever be fun to have a super-difficult 3D platformer? Lost Levels 3D?

When platforming went 3D, most of the 'platformers' actually became adventure games. With the 3DS's's's 3D display, will it be possible to have a purely skill-based game? Just a bunch of platforms, suspended in air? I would have loved to have tried the catforming demo on the 3DS for myself. I hope that it works. It would make for a true functional difference for a 3D display. Maybe one that could even apply to other genres.

URL to share this content (right click and copy link)
Posted: 12/04/10, 22:37:37  - Edited by 
 on: 12/05/10, 16:53:36
[ Share ]
 
Why not sign up for a (free) account and create your own content?
 
First person platforming is an interesting variant. Jumping in FPS games has always kind of sucked, but I thought it worked really well in Metroid Prime. And Mirror's Edge is good, too. Kind of vertiginous, but kind of on purpose.

Using the analog stick also removes some of that immediacy. Maybe you could approximate the snappiness of 2D platforming by making the levels and control orthogonal on the D-Pad, like in Other M. Maybe the 3D effect would make that possible. And maybe Landstalkers and its ilk would actually become playable!

I want to see Q-Bert in 3D.
Posted: 12/06/10, 20:53:50
I want to see a new Jumping Flash! game.
Posted: 12/06/10, 21:00:01
You can play those bouncy treetop levels in Pac-Man... World 2, maybe?
Posted: 12/06/10, 21:13:45
Ugh, first-person platforming is the worst. I wanted to like Mirror's Edge, but it was fucking trial and error to the extreme. It's at least tolerable in Metroid Prime, because it's so limited.
Posted: 12/06/10, 21:21:32
Mirror's Edge is a bit too unforgiving, and it has a lot of design flaws, but I liked the foundation. Thrilling. It would be crazy in 3D. Some people would probably throw up.
Posted: 12/06/10, 21:40:30
I don't know if it's just me but judging distances in 1st person is much tougher than it is in 2D.
The jumping in Metroid Prime was ok I guess but nowhere near the ease it is in 2D.

The problem with all 1st peron games is everyone thinks from the start "OH HEY! SHOOTER!!" like they did with Red Steel 2, Metroid Prime or those superficial shooting elements in Mirror's Edge.
Posted: 12/06/10, 23:03:44
I've never had issues platforming in 3D. Hell, even in Supar Mario Galaxy 2 I was just long jumping to single blocks floating in the abyss instead of using the Cloud Suit to make platforms. That's when the camera's in a position I like.

Wonky cameras do fuck me up. Fallen to my death a couple of times in Epic Mickey because of the camera.
Posted: 12/07/10, 00:52:23
@Simbabbad
@Het_Nkik

You can re adjust it behind you though, with the 'C' button.
Posted: 12/07/10, 02:05:03
Browse    1  2