A Nintendo community
for the fans, by the fans!
Browse    1  2  3  4  5  
Games That Fall Short of Their Potential [roundtable]
Let's list off some games that could have, or should have been great but for one reason or another they fell short.

First up, Gears of War 2.

Speaking strictly on the multiplayer for this one. The mechanics were solid, the weapon balance was better than the first, they were on the right track. And then it was all for nothing as glitch after glitch plagued the multiplayer, matchmaking times were incredibly long and most of the time the game felt worse than the original Gear's terrible host advantage.

Such a disappointment.

Now that Gears 3 has (almost) been announced, will Epic finally capitalize on the potential this series offers on a MP level?

URL to share this content (right click and copy link)
Posted: 04/09/10, 20:33:57  - Edited by 
 on: 02/24/11, 23:12:04
[ Share ]
Why not sign up for a (free) account and create your own content?
PSU was six person questing.

But yeah, it was such a HUGE disappointment. Ugh, now I'm sad. I haven't played enough of PS0 to form an opinion.
Posted: 04/12/10, 21:42:42
Het_Nkik said:
PSU was six person questing.

But yeah, it was such a HUGE disappointment. Ugh, now I'm sad. I haven't played enough of PS0 to form an opinion.
I'll offer an opinion. Not as good as PSO, but a lot better than PSU.
Posted: 04/12/10, 22:07:13
Phantasy Star Zero heals all wounds. It's awesome.
Posted: 04/12/10, 22:07:36
To name two...

Posted: 04/12/10, 22:25:54  - Edited by 
 on: 04/12/10, 22:27:41
Simbabbad said:

Come on man. Didn't you see that coming a mile away? It was obvious this would be the new Black & White. It was just a repetitive toy.

Since Black & White I avoid those kind of "games" like the plague. I had fun with the Spore editor for two days though.

No, I didn't. It's not as if the guy hasn't made some incredibly compelling software in the past. Sim City is outstanding. Spore had less depth than The Sims 3... a game I actually liked, which was incredibly disappointing. He ripped off a bunch of established genres of games, ie the rts, the turn based strategy game, the 3rd person action game... and proceeded to do each portion exponentially worse than even games that are considered "bad" in said genre. The game sucked and had no redeeming qualities outside of the editing tools...which coming from Maxis and Will Wright is absolutely shocking, it's probably the only time I can ever say I've played one of his games as was absolutely blown away at how bad it was. Say what you like about Sim City or The Sims, they are infinitely re playable and can last you literally forever if you like them. Nothing about the core game of Spore retains that inherent quality of all of his other games. Unless you really just dig making stuff and uploading it, you will be done with Spore within ten hours. The only worthwhile phase of the game is the space phase and even that gets boring after an hour or two.

Without exception the most disappointing piece of software I've ever purchased.
Posted: 04/13/10, 04:43:08

Take that, Anand!
Posted: 04/15/10, 05:15:41

Agreed there. Yoshi's Story sucked so bad. DID NOT LIKE.
Posted: 04/15/10, 05:33:40
Yeah I was so hyped for Yoshi's Story after Island and eh...

Also Yoshi's Island 2, though seeing as it wasn't even developed by Nintendo I kind of set my expectations low from the start.
Posted: 04/15/10, 06:33:07
I love Yoshi's Story, and I played it after Yoshi's Island
Posted: 04/15/10, 06:53:31

Agreed. I liked Yoshi's Island DS, but it felt more like Yoshi's Island Plus than an actual sequel.


Hey, you're not alone in that. I mean I definitely disliked it personally, but apparently Story had more to it than I cared to find out about. To be fair though, it had a lot to live up to, and to this day I just cannot separate it out and look at it objectively.
Posted: 04/15/10, 19:56:31
Yoshi's Island 2 on DS is a better game than Yoshi's Story.... but that ain't saying' much.

Seriously, that game was one of the most disappointing releases from Nintendo during the N64 era. Pretty much everything else they released was pure *gold* but Yoshi's Story was just terrible IMHO.

Pokémon Snap sucked too, but that game doesn't really fit into this topic discussion. It didn't really have any potential to live up to. I still didn't like it, though.
Posted: 04/15/10, 20:38:26

This one sure as hell didn't live up to the bar set by Harvest Moon (SNES) and Harvest Moon 64. And no HM game really has come close, since. I suppose the GBA game was good, though, and Rune Factory is great.
Posted: 04/15/10, 20:45:03

The Playstation 1 game (Back to Nature, I think?) was very good. I would say about the same level as the N64, although it seemed to be harder to me for some reason.
Posted: 04/15/10, 21:28:58
I admit total ignorance of the "Harvest Moon" main series besides watching my cousin play it but now that I am playing Rune Factory, I am curious... are there things Harvest Moon does that Rune Factory DOESN'T? It seems to me like Harvest Moon +, though some people might not want dungeon crawling in their farm sim.

I also have to admit I'm a bit turned off by having to use monsters instead of farm animals. I want cows and chickens! And turtles. Farms have turtles, right? But they don't eat them, they just keep them around as pets.
Posted: 04/15/10, 22:21:18

Any relation to you Zero?

There was some magic turtle or something that gave you upgrade IIRC.
Posted: 04/15/10, 22:32:28
Yeah, Rune Factory really is Harvest Moon Plus. Almost everything is taken to a new level, plus you've got dungeons and an overarching story that is not just "save the farm". I only played the first Rune Factory on DS, but places where Harvest Moon still shines is character relationships, and its more meaningful festivals. It also has a more "cutesy" style, if that makes sense. I really like what they did with Rune Factory, though. Probably the best spin-off/inspired-by game I've ever played.

@ stephen08

Yeah, I've heard the PS1 Harvest Moon was good, but I never played it. Harvest Moon 64 is my favourite of the series and choosing it over WWF Wrestlemania 2000 was one of the toughest choices I ever made but I'm happy I made that choice. God damn $79.99 N64 games.
Posted: 04/15/10, 22:33:46  - Edited by 
 on: 04/15/10, 22:41:44
Dark Void on the 360 and PS3. The DSi version was soooo much better.
Posted: 04/15/10, 22:53:13

You have a PS3 right? It's on PSN I believe. There is still time!
Posted: 04/15/10, 23:05:38

It's not. Sony is too busy releasing enduring classics such as Ford Racing, Spec Ops, Ten Pin Alley or XS Junior League Dodgeball.
Posted: 04/16/10, 04:24:49
Right on!

You rat bastards!!

I love that Nintendo made Yoshi's Story. It's so fucking weird and idiosyncratic. Plus, the music is amazing, and it's probably still the most beautiful 2D game ever made.
Posted: 04/16/10, 05:07:16  - Edited by 
 on: 04/16/10, 05:11:59
Browse    1  2  3  4  5